Thanks Santoch. I did see that one a while ago, I really like that one. I'm a little concerned that I won't be able to get people to commit to a style (We're not radegast yet). I like the simplicity of your also, I'm just worried I'm not giving enough feedback.
I'd really like to give people meaningful feedback, although good in means good out. I'd really love to grow my club, I don't think it can survive as is. Right now it's a mess of random people, I'd love to get to the point of giving the maltose falcons a run at the comps and raise some money for charity.
Denny, I absolutely believe the bjcp sheet is better and more thorough then whatever I come up with, I just think if I throw a thousand check boxes and a full page score sheet per beer at my club I'll get riots.