If you want to emphasize the big of big bug, you might consider putting a really small pint glass next to the bug.
Sorry you feel everyone is being overly negative, but you did ask for honest feedback. People do want breweries to succeed, and the feedback you are getting is to push you in the right direction. They are not trying to discourage you, they are trying to point out where they think you need to improve. It is possible that you can still be successful with a logo that some people don't like, with a story that some perceive as poorly written and somewhat nonsensical, or a website some view as unattractive. There is a lot of good beer in the market, so you need to consider every thing you can do to help yourself. Or not.