Sorry it took this long to respond. You have two options, Mash House has long been a great brewpub, but their brewer left last year for greener pastures so I'm not sure the beer is still as awesome or not. The other option is Huske Hardware House and to be honest I have never been a fan. I cannot think of any great beer bar in Fayettenam. Grapes & Hops was a good beer store at one time, but I haven't been there in forever.
Stop the presses, there is a Mac's Speed Shop in Fayetteville. 482 N. McPherson Church Rd
Fayetteville, NC 28303 - they generally have a pretty stellar beer selection at the other locations and the cue is good too.
That's about it.